Skip to content

How to Write Without Approval: Reasons to Keep Writing When it’s Tough

Posted in anxiety, Creative Writing, creativity, discipline, fairy tales, fear, finishing your novel, genre fiction, Getting published, Independent Publishing, Learning to Write, Literature, living the dream, making a living as a writer, motivation for writers, novels, overcoming fear, Productivity for creatives, Rejections, self publishing, self-doubt, Storytelling, transcendence, Truth, and writing life

Old Books Piled On Shelves with Writing Tools

 

The Need For Approval

For many of us, the quest for approval is one of the reasons to keep writing. I imagine once you’ve a horde of adoring fans hanging on your every word, and swathes of bookstore real estate burgeoning with your work – if you’re Neil Gaiman or Stephen King – you don’t worry about approval. You have it.

But the need for approval is real for the rest of us. And however brave a face we may put on it, we writers care about it. We crave it.

I assume it’s not just me.

There are three kinds of approval available to writers:

• an offer of representation from an agent or a contract from a publisher
• book sales and royalty checks
• positive reviews and emails from readers

For a writer pursuing the “traditional route” to publication, all three should come in series. If you’re independent, you have to skip the first and go it alone. Even if your book sales are dismal, as a traditionally published author you have a professional shoulder to cry on and an encouraging voice urging you to complete the next book. If you’re an indie and your book doesn’t sell – the chances are it won’t, because most books never do – you’re alone in the dark silence.

Keep Calm and Carry On

And yet somehow, you find reasons to keep writing, and you carry on.

Maybe you chew your fingernails to the raw; maybe you polish off a bottle of wine and weep yourself to sleep; maybe you don’t write for a week; maybe you kick and curse and rage against the night sky.

But eventually you stop biting your finger nails; you sober up and dowse yourself under a cold shower; you reboot your word processor; you take a deep breath and steel your nerve.

And you write.

Painting of a Woman Reading

It doesn’t take much to reignite a true writer’s passion and send her back, eyes glittering with hope, to the keyboard. A word of encouragement from a friend can do it. A good review is better. A single, solitary sale is more than enough. In a TV interview way back when, Ray Bradbury, talking about his early struggles, said,

“Even one sale a year is enough to keep your spirits up.”

So true.

But wait. This means there’s another motive; something that keeps us writing that has nothing to do with approval. And that leads us on to a more fundamental question: why write at all?

Why Do Writers Write?

Why do so many of us keep writing, even as we balance our hopes and word processors on the unstable foundation of a mountain of rejection slips? Or when another week passes and not a single book sells? What drives a writer to get up every day and cast her words into the void: the dark chamber from which, often, not even the faintest of echoes return?

William Faulkner, answering questions after a lecture to students at the University of Virginia, Charlottesville, said,

“I think that no writer is ever quite satisfied with the book — that’s why he writes another one; that he is trying to put on paper something that is going to be a little better.”

I don’t doubt that’s true.

But is it one of the main reasons to keep writing, to carry on? Are we driven by dissatisfaction? If so, we’re all condemned to the same fate as the mythical Sisyphus, toiling at an impossible task: the quest for the perfect book.

Woman Searching For A Book

For my part, I feel compelled to write. I don’t mean to romanticize or glorify that compulsion. I see it as an illness. It goes against all reason to persist in this futile comedy of errors played to an audience of mirrors. Most of the time I feel like the ghost of a crazed clown turning tricks in an abandoned circus.

But I play on. I can’t stop.

I claim no great literary merit for my fictional output. I write about talking monkeys, flying to the moon in air balloons, kids who travel back in time, sword-wielding teens descended from dragons, stuff like that; pure flights of fancy. I feel a much greater kindred with the old-time storyteller improvising by the hearth fire, than the Mistress of Letters with her Muse and quill.

And I say that without a word of shame. I’m not a snob about art, music, or literature. I prefer the rough-cut of the popular to the fine polish of the Academy. Or at least, I see no sense in which a Booker Prize-winning story is any more a story than anything published in Amazing Stories or The Beano.

Amazing Stories with tales written by H. G. Wells & Jules Verne

All that interests me is telling stories. That’s it. I am compelled to tell stories.

I can echo the words of Italo Calvino, one of my literary heroes, who wrote in a letter to a friend,

“I’m a regular guy, I like well-defined outlines… My stories are full of facts; they have a beginning and an end. For that reason they will never be able to find success with the critics, nor occupy a place in contemporary literature.”

My writing may not have great literary merit, but the stories I tell are worth telling. Is there a story that isn’t worth telling?

Reading other people's books can often provide reasons to keep writing

I can’t imagine life without writing.

If I was on the proverbial desert island with no laptop, no pen, no paper; I would write stories in the sand. Imprison me in solitary confinement; I will scratch stories on the walls, in my own blood if I must. Cut out my tongue, chop off my hands. I will write. I will find a way.

Everything that writing involves – from the welling-up of an idea, to developing a structure to support and express it, to crafting the words which will communicate it, to punching out the letters which form those words – it’s all integral to my life, to my identity. It’s what I am.

It’s dangerous, that. Do you see?

I’ll write without approval. But I still want it. And I suffer without it. I’m compelled to keep on anyway, with or without approval. Approval doesn’t determine whether I write or not, but it plays a part in my happiness as a writer.

Reading and Writing

There Are Several Reasons to Keep Writing

I very much want people to read my stories, to connect to them, to enjoy them, to feel that life is richer, at least a little, for reading them. Storytelling is about sharing, connecting, finding the common treasures we all hold. The difference between living without telling stories and storytelling is the difference between dining alone and cooking for friends.

If I can’t write for a time, I miss it as I might a lover. The agitation and the yearning only increase in intensity the longer it continues. I become restless, I mope, get depressed. It’s like fasting. The longer I fast, the hungrier I get. There’s a gnawing emptiness deep in the pit of my being. I fade, weaken, and sicken. If writing is living, then without it, I’ll die.

That’s the dark, dangerous and negative aspect of the illness: the addiction, compulsion, dependency, symptoms of withdrawal.

I write.

I get my fix.

But let me try to describe the high. As reasons to keep writing go, it’s a powerful one. I think it’s the high which provides the answer to the question of why writers write even without approval, recognition, or sales. And represented or indie, that’s most of us.

Writing has inherent rewards. It delivers an extraordinary “kick.”

Searching for Books in a Book Store

I suspect it’s not just writers, but people working in any creative field, who experience this high. It’s often referred to as being “in the zone” or experiencing “flow.”

When I’m writing a story, the experience is the closest I’ll ever get to something I might describe as “spiritual.” Like a religious ritual, the act of writing involves a liturgy expressed in physical activity, emotional engagement, and intellectual exultation. The experience of writing or telling a story is to lift the curtain on a theater of the soul; a sacrament of meaning and truth which leads to a deep communion – a common union – with life.

Really? I mean, really?

Yes. Really.

Even when I’m writing about talking monkeys, flying to the moon in air balloons, kids who travel back in time, sword-wielding teens descended from dragons, stuff like that?

Especially when I’m writing about stuff like that. Didn’t anyone ever explain that fairy tales are as much depositories of truth as science is the guardian of facts?

Many great authors wrote a lot of letters

When I’m “in the zone” the experience of storytelling is a dichotomous fusion of transcendence and connection. Transcendent because it’s as if I’ve entered another plane of existence, an alternate reality; connected because the story, the world, imagery, and words become cogent, unified, and whole. I become utterly absorbed as the boundaries between self and story, and story and reality, melt away.
It’s magic.

There’s no other hit comes close.

And that’s why I write. Storytelling is intrinsic to my well-being; as essential as nature, food, coffee, and friends.

Writing a Feast of Words

And that’s how to write without approval.

Tell your story for its own sake. Yes, once you have a complete work, you’ll want publication, approval, recognition, success. But that can wait and come if it will. By the time that happens (or doesn’t) the story is told. Once you get to “the end,” the personal, interior experience of writing is done; the story petrifies and becomes nothing but an artifact in the archaeology of memory. You leave it in the dust, perplexed, wondering how it ever seemed such a vital and vibrant thing, and move on to the next story urging its telling.

No sane person would ever write to obtain approval. The desire for approval is real, and the want of it, uncomfortable. But it must never be the reason why we write.

That’s not why we do it.

So even without approval, I’ll write and write, and keep writing.

I’ll write for as long as there are stories to tell. You see, I have no choice.

divider_line

800px-Kulikov_Writer_E.N.Chirikov_1904

If you’ve enjoyed this post or if you haven’t, I would love to read your insights, experiences, thoughts, critiques, or reflections in the comments below. Please share this post on your social media. That would be a lovely thing to do.

divider_line

***

Image credits: all images (apart from the book covers of my novels and the photo of me) are in the Public Domain and were sourced via the Creative Commons. Click on the image to reveal the name of the artist and the work in the address bar.

Sharing is caring - spread the word!

Enjoy this blog? Enter your email. I'll let you know when there's a new post and add you to the Clockwork Press mailing list.

Buy Me a Coffee!

4 Comments

  1. Yet another excellent blog post. You know, Austin, I don’t think I’ve come across anyone who puts it in words quite as well as you do. You have literally given form to my exact thoughts and feelings when it comes to the writing process: The ailment, the compulsion, the withdrawals, the yearning…I become downright irritable when I’m not writing (or in the case of the last couple of months, editing). I physically and emotionally need to be working on one of my novels in some way, shape or form; I need to be with my characters, or I feel empty. Like a ship without an anchor, or a balloon released by a child–I often feel like I’m drifting, and like the current (be it water or air) is taking me nowhere. The characters and their stories are my anchor, my reason, the company I willingly keep in my head–and frequently question my own sanity over when I prefer their company to those of living flesh.

    I guess what I’m trying to say is, you’re not alone. I don’t know if the majority of writers suffer the same affliction, or if it’s a handful of us at most–but I do know I take comfort in knowing someone else who doesn’t glorify it, but welcomes it just the same. After all, a creative high is much better than a chemical one, no?

    As always, thanks so much for sharing your insights with the rest of us. It’s absolutely liberating, knowing another writer as consumed by their work as you are. 🙂

    February 18, 2017
    |Reply
    • Austin Hackney
      Austin Hackney

      Hi Shannon. Your kind and generous comment is in itself a masterpiece!

      “Like a ship without an anchor, or a balloon released by a child…” Beautifully and precisely phrased.

      The reassurance works both ways. It’s comforting to know I’m not the only one. My friend Jane Yolen (who doesn’t need to struggle for approval, as she’s been writing for half a century and published hundreds of books), read this and wrote me an email to say “a lot of this defines me.” But she also said that the high I refer to is better styled, from her perspective, as “joy.” Jane’s use of that word gave me pause for thought. I did wonder if the metaphor of illness and addiction – while accurate in many ways – is perhaps too negative.

      I prefer your analogy of companionship.

      But however we try and express it, we are clearly not alone.

      I’m happy to read that you are editing. Do you enjoy it? Some do, some don’t, but it’s an exciting stage. Some of the madness is over, and with a cooler mind, the crafts-person steps up to take over the work.

      Thank you once again for taking the trouble to comment. It means a lot to know someone is reading this stuff!

      Wishing you every good thing,

      A.

      February 19, 2017
      |Reply
      • I think each analogy contains its own truth, and that we’re likely to experience it in different ways; depending on our moods, the specific scene or story we’re working on, or even what character we’re working with. 🙂 I’ve known joy as well, as I’m sure you have, too. Perhaps it’s something we’ll experience more than the addictive high once we’ve established ourselves more in the literary world–whether we have ten die-hard readers, or ten thousand. I kind of see the joy aspect as a second childhood; I felt joy before I knew half of the technical ins and outs of writing (at least that I do, now), and it’s something I hope to reclaim in the future. I’m sure you will, too. 🙂

        Lol, some of the time I enjoy it. Mostly, I enjoy the knowledge that the stories are becoming more refined each time I go over them, and that while doing it, I’m immersing myself in the world and communicating with my characters (my muses) once again. Other times, such as when I hit a particularly difficult snag, I could hang the whole process. xD Overall though, it’s rewarding.

        How about you? How do you feel during the editorial stage?

        Likewise, I wish you the best of success–both in your literary endeavours, and in the other aspects of your life. Should I think of a specific topic, I’ll be sure to send a message your way. ^^

        Hope the remainder of your weekend is fantastic!

        -Shannon-

        February 19, 2017
        |Reply
        • Austin Hackney
          Austin Hackney

          Dear Shannon,

          Wise words, indeed! Thank you for such a significant contribution.

          Thinking of what you term a “second childhood,” I certainly think “being in the zone” is exactly the same mental state as when, as children, we used to play our “imagination games.” So utterly absorbed in the the story and the characters that we genuinely didn’t hear the frustrated adult trying to call us in for supper! That’s a blissful state, a joyful state, for sure. I can understand those writers who eschew the ambition to write (fiction) professionally. Why spoil the purity of that interior experience by worrying if it will sell? But there I think we have to draw careful lines and learn to move between states: the free creativity of original storytelling must be liberated from all other concerns; and then, once the story is told, can come the critic and the marketeer; but you sure don’t want them all in the same room together.

          Which brings me on to editing. Editing (or the several rounds of editing) is an aspect of writing which I love. It’s the stage at which the craftsperson steps into play to make sense out of the chaos of colorful creativity the spontaneous artist left behind; to re-order things, chisel in the fine details, polish the surfaces. I do enjoy editing very much.

          But I won’t say more about it here and now, as it is an excellent idea for a blog post. So thank you for that! I shall write about it soon.

          Thanks again for your generous input.

          Be well,

          A.

          February 20, 2017
          |Reply

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: